Wacom Graphire vs Intuos Tablet Review
- Product:
- Wacom Intuos3 6x8 Tablet (company site)
- What’s Good:
- Lots of Settings, Quick Keys, Included Software
- What’s Bad:
- Expensive, Required Desk Space
This review is based on the Graphire2 4x5 vs Intuos3 6x8. Something I have also considered to be the consumer and professional style.
I have owned the Graphire tablet since 2002 and just recently a trip to PhotoshopWorld where they released the new Intuos3, I convinced
myself that the more expensive Intuos model was worth the price after having the time to experiment and physically see the difference. Shortly after
I returned home, I ordered the middle sized 6x8 tablet. One step up from the smallest 4x5 model.
Now that I have been using both for a little while, one question I have seen on many forums has been. Is the Graphire good enough or should I
have the Intuos? Side Note: I also had time to play with the amazing 18SX Cintiq.
Very expensive but works much better then I would have thought.
Graphire Package *I'm using a Graphire2 tablet with Graphire3 Pen. Pens are identical.
- Basic Tablet
- Pen with 512 levels of pressure sensitivity
- Graphire2 has a pen stand, Graphire3 has it built into the top of the tablet.
- 3 button Mouse plastic bottom (Graphire2 model)
- Drivers CD
- Software: Photoshop Elements 2 / Corel Painter Essentials 2 / nik Color Efex Pro 2 GE
- Software Discounts
- 4x5 Price: approx $100 USD (6x8: $200 USD)
Intuos3 Package
- Tablet with custom buttons and touch strips
- Pen with 1024 levels of pressure sensitivity / and tilt sensitivity
- Pen Stand
- 5 extra pen tips(nibs). 3 Regulars, 1 brush-like feel, 1 high friction feel
- 5 button Mouse with felt bottom
- Drivers CD
- Software: Photoshop Elements 3 ($99 Value) / Corel Painter Essentials 2 / nik Color Efex Pro 2 IE / Wacom Brushes 2
- Eligible for software discounts. Included in the box was a coupon for 50% off Photoshop CS
- 4x5 Price: approx $200 USD (6x8: $330 USD)
View differences chart on Wacom.com
Photos

Graphire2, Graphire3 and
Intuos3 Pen

Graphire2 and
Intuos3 Tablet

Graphire2 and
Intuos3 Mouse
My Thoughts
- The Intuos surface has a much softer feel compared to the hard plastic surface of the Graphire2 tablet. The Intuos3 really gave me the feeling of my hand gliding across the surface effortlessly.
- The Pen nibs do wear down. After using my Graphire3 pen for 3 months, there has been a flat edge developing.
- The Intuos3 has a larger pen and is all one piece with a soft rubber grip. I have had days where the 2 piece graphire pen became really irritating rubbing against my thumb where the pieces connect.
- The double pressure is noticeable and the pen gives a better feeling of how hard you are pressing. This is even more noticeable in the options as opposed to photoshop.
- The touch strips on the Intuos3 are cool and useful but I found the touch pad on a laptop for scrolling does a better job.
- The express keys are really useful and can be customized to anything. My setup at the time of this post (note that the 4x5 only has 1 set on the left):
- Express Keys Left: Shift, Ctrl, Alt, Space
Touch Strip: page scroll
- Express Keys Right: Firefox, Explorer, Enter, Alt+F4
Touch Strip: brush scroll using [ ] keys
- The included software is one generation old. Up until Photoshop Elements 3 was released just a few month ago, Elements 2 was $99USD by itself. Just last week the Graphire tablets upgrade to Elements 2 but there has been no talk or indication that they will upgrade to Elements 3.
My Thoughts on Size
- If your looking for a tablet that will travel with you, consider a 4x5. The size of the 6x8 surface and then the extended areas for the new quick keys required lots of desk space.
- The Graphire3 tablet has the pen holder built into the top (similar to a palm pilot). Great for travel so you don't lose or break your pen.
- The 6x8 gives you more accuracy for short movements on the screen but for every day tasks, expect your hand to travel more.
- If you plan on using the mouse, be aware that you must use it within the defined area. A 4x5 area may be too small.
REVIEW UPDATE: More Thoughts on Size
A large number of comments is asking aboout what size to buy. My general rule is that the 4x5 is a great portable tablet that works great for laptops. If you are using a monitor bigger then 19", get the 6x8. However, I find the 6x8 too big for a laptop resolution, the 4x5 is too small for a 20" monitor. The tablet to screen ratio is 1:1 so you really need to get a tablet sized based on the resolution you work at to maintain a comfortable cursor speed on screen.
Overall I'm satisfied with both and will continue to use them on a regular basis. The Intuos 6x8 attached to my desktop and the Graphire 4x5 connected to my laptop.
Comments
Bill Pearson - January 15, 2005 11:40 PM
Thank you ... very helpful.
Bill
Tom Hoffmann - January 24, 2005 1:38 AM
I've been using the Graphire 3 6x8 for about 8 month's now and I wouldn't trade it for anything. I like how the two position button on the sylist is set to single click or double click. Although you can tap it too. For doing precision drawing's or graphic's it can't be beat. It is well worth the money, and I would recomend it to all graphic designer's, 3D modeler's, and artist's.
Laura Barnard - February 27, 2005 10:13 AM
Could you give me your opinion on the difference between the Intuos 2 and the Intuos 3? I have had neither and I am in the market to buy one. I do Patent Illustrations and I use mainly Illustrator and Visio (sometimes AutoCad). There is a one hundred dollar difference in the two and I was wondering if there is much of a difference in the functionality between them.
Thanks,
Laura
Stephen DesRoches - May 25, 2005 2:42 PM
Another Advantage.
Wacom announced today that registered users of the Intuos Tablet could purchase Photoshop CS2 for $299. Considering the Intuos tablets start at $200 USD, the $300 discount isn't that bad if you plan on buying both.
Offer ends June 30th, 2005.
Birru - June 30, 2005 7:20 PM
I just "downgraded" from an Intuos2 6x8 to a Graphire Bluetooth 6x8. I use the tablet a lot on the go with my PowerBook.
The Intuos2 is more precise. I notice it more with pen movement than pressure though. The Graphire Bluetooth does offer enough precision to work accurately on a large, high resolution monitor though. It's more than good enough for pro level work on the go.
The Graphire Bluetooth seems more durably constructed than my Intuos2, which had a couple of the tabs that lock the case together snap off, probably due to some torsion while in my bag. It's thicker and more resistant to flexing, and also has less handrest space on either side of the active area, making it a better fit in my bag too.
Range is very good, and there's no lag. I had interference once, during a heavy Mac/PC WiFi file transfer. No issues at all during heavy WiFi internet activity.
If you have a PowerBook, or x86 laptop with built in bluetooth, it's just about perfect as a portable solution, other than maybe a tablet PC. You also no longer have to worry about the Graphire's chintzy USB cord shorting out on the Bluetooth model.
Bjarni Wark bj2design - December 20, 2005 5:27 PM
This has been very helpful in deceiding which wacom tablet to get. It was good to read that the Graphire Pen comes with 512 levels of pressure sensitivity.
Neeki - December 22, 2005 5:20 PM
I'm planning on buying a graphire tablet, I'm considering either the 3x5 or 6x8...I have a question....does the size of the tablet affect the image drawn, like if youuse the smaller tablet does it leave a bigger mark?
Stephen DesRoches - December 22, 2005 7:07 PM
Neeki: yes. The same distance traveled on the smaller tablet will leave a longer mark on screen.
This is assuming you are using them both at the same screen resolution. The tablet pad size is directly related to the resolution of your monitor so think of it like looking at your screen scaled down on to the tablet surface.
Bjarni Wark - December 22, 2005 8:08 PM
Hi Stephen,
I have read there is not much difference at all between the Graphire and Intuos models. Do you still recommend the 6x8 size over that of the 4x5 for desktop use. I am concerned that the 4x5 might be to restrictive. I would like to use it for logo development but also experiement with it to see if it is a valuable asset for work in general. What kind of work do you use your wacom for, illustration, photograghic or design?
Murugan - January 1, 2006 3:07 AM
Iam planning on buying a cheaper graphire version but the prices are differnt in every store that I look in....
I want to know the difference between graphire 3 vs graphire 4
which one is better? and whats the additional advantages on the better one?
I was going to go for a 6X8 but after reading this and my computer table is really small so Iam just going to go for the 4X5 one....
can someone please email me muruganc@gmail.com with answers? and if u are planning on selling your old one also let me know, I might buy it :) Thnx in advance :)
MSN: dabrowndevil@hotmail.com
AIM: rmcmurugan@aol.com
RAL - January 5, 2006 2:00 PM
DO YOU HAVE TO USE THE SUPPLIED MOUSE, OR CAN YOU USE YOUR OWN?
Lee - January 19, 2006 12:22 PM
I have an intuos and a graphire 3 both 6x8. The intuos is by far better. The tracking is way better and the distance that you have between the pen and the tablet is farther for the intuos. For the graphire you almost always have to keep your tip .2 inches away from the tablet in order for it to track. Intuos is the way to go!!
John Lacson - January 21, 2006 7:23 AM
I have been using a Graphire 3 for the past few years and I've been very happy with it. Although I've always wanted the higher end models, I use it with my 12" powerbook, so a small 4x5 intuos didn't make sense... I stuck with the cheaper Graphire... until recently.
I was eying the new 6x8 Intuos 3 and already placed an order for one... looked really cool, wasn't too expensive, had those shortcut buttons... I was sold! although it wouldn't fit my laptop bag, I was gonna delegate it to my desktop system at home, and my trusty Graphire would still go with me and my notebook.
As luck would have it, since the Intuos 3 is out... Wacom Philippines decided to go on sale with all their unsold Intuos 2 models... I got the mother 12" x 18" Intuos 2 at a steal!!!! (under $200) Although it is the older model, it has all the functions I needed. Still unopened and still with Wacom's warranty, I got it straight from their warehouse here in the Philippines. I was the lucky one who called in first. About 30 other graphic artists after me tried... but I got it first!!! Hehehehe.
I'm sure the new Intuos 3 is great!!! And had there not been a Wacom sale, I would've gotten the 6x8 model.
Wacom rocks!!!! :)
Samantha - June 13, 2006 5:04 PM
Hello! Very good review, it was very helpful. My friend recently bought a tablet online and I'm kinda into art myself so I'm looking for a small one. I measured out 4x5 and it's really small and the 6x8 is a much better size for me, but it seems from all the reviews I've gotten it's not a great size for travel. I'm torn between the Graphire, the Intuos, and an Adesso I found on Amazon.com. There are too many tablets to choose from! But I guess a big selection is better. But thatnks for the review, it's helped me a lot!
Melissa - July 25, 2006 4:20 PM
I recently upgraded from an original intuos 6x8(purchased for an amazing price on ebay), to an intuos 3 6x11 Wide Format tablet. I use it with my apple g5 and a 20" Widescreen display. I am a professional Graphic designer and I can no longer use a mouse! These tablets, once you get really familiar with them, are much more efficient and accurate than any mouse I've found. This is my personal set up at home, but at work we have 4x5 Graphire tablets. They are still better than a mouse, but not as good as my intuos.
The intuos 3 has vastly improved over their original Intuos model. The pen is more comfortable, the new scroll wheels are a great feature for paging up and down in Indesign, illustrator and other programs. Even surfing the web.
If you have the desk space for a wide format tablet, you will not regret it. The 4x5 that I use at work is too restrictive for fluid hand movements across it. And as mentioned before the Graphire is more jumpy and less accurate. The other tablet that I've been dying to try is the 6x8 Bluetooth Graphire. I love the wireless feature. Not only would it free up a USB port. It would be great for travel, and lets face it, who likes the look of a mess of cords on your desk!
Maria Vang - October 6, 2006 1:33 PM
I am a graphic designer and I bought my Intuos3 a few months ago. Ever since then I can't stop wondering how I have been able to design anything before that. The price was a little high for me but it was worth every penny. I am really happy with it.
Some people say that the shortcut buttons are almost useless but I personally use them a lot. I am used to using shortcuts a lot and it would have been unhandy if I had to reach for my keyboard every time I needed a shortcut.
The pen is really comfortable and it has become a part of my hand.
I have to admit though that I don't use the mouse from the package. I use my own Logitech mouse since I find the Wacom mouse really uncomfortable (not the best shape for my hand).
Anyway, I would recommend Wacom Intuos 3 to anyone who asks for my opinion.
Julian - November 5, 2006 10:10 AM
Hi,
I want to buy a Wacom tablet. I just dont know if I should buy the Graphire4 classic XL or the Intuos A5.
The Graphire is much cheaper but I dont know if it is as good or good enough for me.
The only difference I can see between the two is that the Intuos has more pressure levels and more buttons on the tablet itself, but aren't 512 pressure levels enough ?
I would be thankful for any advice !
Thanks alot
Elizabeth - November 30, 2006 2:47 PM
I was wondering whether or not my husband's Christmas gift was going to be useful to him. I bought the intuous2 6x8 tablet and now I am almost certain that I chose well. Thanks for all of the reviews!
chris - December 2, 2006 5:24 AM
Is anyone using Manga Studio EX? Someone said it works with intuos 2 and a few others but did not mention intuos3.
Linda - December 10, 2006 10:13 AM
Has any one got any thoughts about the Intuos3 A5 wide - what are the benefits over the Intuos3 A5?
Scott - December 27, 2006 5:33 PM
I'm interested in upgrading my Graphire4 to an Intuos, because the biggest problem I have is the surface. I'm like most of the other users here, and I LOVE my Graphire, but I have to carry a small bottle of baby powder (!) to sprinkle on it periodically. The plastic cover causes my sweaty hands to stick as I'm drawing a stroke across the surface. It's really annoying when trying to work in Photoshop/Sketchbook! I think I've been able to pick out that the Intuos has a better drawing surface. Has anyone had any experience with this?
Jim - December 29, 2006 11:46 AM
Hi there,
I am torn between the Graphire 4 and Intuos 3...Any suggestions?
What I will be using it for is drawing. I have been using Microsoft Paint to draw/illustrate for cards, but that's using my mouse! LOL
I am sure that by purchasing a WACOM product, my drawings will improve and my wrist won't hurt as much!
Can someone please tell me if the Graphire model is good enough for drawing/paint?
Please and thanks...
J.
Sasha Irla - January 22, 2007 11:15 AM
Hi guys, so far for a few years now i have been painting fantasy art in photoshop with my mouse and am busy saving for a tablet, The price difference is a lot between the two but the advantages are also getting to me...
One question i have: You guys said that the tablet relates to your screens resolution.
I am currently running a 21" monitor, but i am condering to get the 4x5 tablet for painting and quite fine, detailed work. do you think this is a good idea or do you think i should opt for the larger graphire model, instead of the smaller intuos model.
Reply asap and thanks for this thread, it has been a great help :D
Thanks, Sasha.
neezee - February 19, 2007 2:53 AM
you can specify a certain area with the new wacoms but 21" with a 4*5 is quite small but better than the grapphire i guess, so you could use your 4*5 with fine detail
eurogypsy - April 3, 2007 4:57 PM
I'm looking into buying the intuos 6x8 tablet because the foodprint enables me to haul it around in a bag with my laptop. Question does the tablet auto-scale to the canvas size selected? by that I mean since I'll be working in Photoshop CS2 mainly with a canvas size of 11 x 17 CMYK mode at 300dpi, does this have any bearing on which size tablet I should select?
John - April 6, 2007 10:37 PM
I want to buy my daughter an Intuos3 tablet as she is heavily into drawing manga. I am having a problem deciding on what size to get. I'm leaning towards a 6x8, but I really don't know much about these things. She is using a 19" moniter, if that makes any difference. Can anyone help? Thanks.
Jin Fan - April 14, 2007 8:59 PM
I just ordered an intuos 4x5 for $109. (don't be too happy about the price). The thing is it's refurbished. Please read the following:
Wacom Intuos3 4x5 Drawing Tablet
- Convention Special!!!
- Save Over 50%!!
- Wacom Factory Refurbished
- Wacom Full One Year Warranty
- FREE S&H
Part#: PTZ430WAC-refurb
Manufacturer Part#: PTZ430WAC-refurb
(Qty: 1 x $109.99)
The reason why I order a refurbished one is I never tried graphics tablets before, and I'm in college, major in graphic design. Thought I might need one, but I'm so broke at this point, so daddy promised will buy me one. I want a intuos 3, but dad just saw the deal online and purchased it >.<
Do you think that was a bad idea??? Oh god, is it too late to cancel it???
Jin Fan - April 14, 2007 9:08 PM
One more thing, I just read on Wacom's official website, a refurbished intuo3 4x5 is Price: $179.95. Why are selling so much more than mine ($109) and it's at their official site???
jimmy - April 15, 2007 9:19 AM
if the deal is legit, you'll love it. And it's under warranty so i'd say don't sweat it.
RJ - April 17, 2007 2:04 PM
I've looking to buy a tablet, I started using an intuos3 6x11 that we have at work.
Amazing how good the pressure sensitive feature works, it really provides the feel of a regular brush.
Before purchasing mine (I still haven't) a friend of mine allowed me to use his 4x5 Graphire 2, these are the differences I've found so far.
Size:
It really makes a difference if you want to do detailed work, like precise lines, cartoon type of shadowing. Also if you are drawing long lines, it feels weird with the graphire because a small movement of the hand translates into a very long line in your monitor, the bigger the monitor the larger the line will be.
The 4x6 is a completely portable tablet though, does not take a lot of space and you can take it everyware in a regular backpack.
Pressure Sensitivity:
Although it took me a while to finally find the pressure sensitive brushes in Photoshop elements 2 for the Graphire, also the Graphire does not work with the finest detail you will get with the Intuos. Comparatively you will need to put a lot more effort into the Graphire, the Intuos is amazingly soft, it feels at some point like you are really drawing/painting/inking with a brush.
Surface smoothness:
The Graphire feels bumpy, I'm not sure if this is because my friend is an engineer and used it in the workplace (read: next to dusty machines), or if it is because of the plastic surface in the Graphire, the Intuos3 just feels like gliding.
All in all, as many have said, I think I would still use the Graphire for photo editing, and travel, although I guess I would have to re-touch my cartoons (meaning almost redoing) with the Intous for better quality and detail.
Hope that helps.
Max - May 6, 2007 1:04 PM
About Graphires surface smoothness:
I have never used a tablet but am keen to try one. Cant you just slide a piece of paper between the pen and tablet to stop the affects of sweaty hands and bumpy/grippy surfaces on the tablet?
Frez - May 9, 2007 9:00 PM
Hey I was going to buy the wide screen intus 3 (6x11) and Im kinda affraid to buy it cuz when im researching about it, i keep seeing Photo editing,
I want to be able to draw fine,detailed, drawings on the computer, but thats impossible with mouse, so my question is, can i do that with wacom without having to buy a Cintiq?
Rberg - May 22, 2007 11:37 PM
I know a couple of folks who have taken to taping a piece of paper over the surface of their Graphire to improve the tactile feel of the pen ... the Graphire surface can be quite slick. I tried it and it works. The input from the pen will not be affected by the paper.
Try it - you will like it.
Rberg - May 22, 2007 11:41 PM
There is no difference is the sensitiviy between the Cintiq and the Intuos 3 line of tablets.
the pressure sensitivity is the same as is the resolution and both products use the same pen.
The Cintiq is really designed for those people who spend 8 - 10 - 12 hours slaving over Photoshop or Painter every day.
The answer to your question is that you do not need the Cintiq to do fine detail work. The Intuos 3 6X11 will do what you want and it is a fabulous product!
Roger - May 30, 2007 10:22 AM
I am thinking about buying the Intuos3 A5 (Wide). However, I'm conscious that this range has now been out for almost 3 years. Has anyone heard any rumours regarding any imminent updates to this range (I have a habit of buying technology that almost immediately has a new version released!!)
Cheers,
Roger
Jefferson - June 1, 2007 1:43 PM
To answer Scott and Max about the surface problem when having sweaty hands:
Yes, I use to have the friction problem too. My sweaty hand use to stick to the plastic cover as I was drawing across the surface and the plastic would resist my hand movement. Since Wacom can't make the plastic more slippery, (because the pen would start to slide all over the place) I started using a new product called SmudgeGuard. I'm left-handed and I actually bought it to avoid getting smudges when writing or drawing, but decided to try it on my Wacom tablet as well and it's been excellent! Now, I use it everytime I use my Wacom tablet. No more friction. When wearing this nylon partial glove, my hand slides easily on the surface and the pen continues to keep it's grip on the tablet. So Scott, you can stop pouring the baby powder and Max, you can stop using the paper. Paper would only cover up half your work making hard for you to see what you're actually drawing. So if interested, check this product out at www.SmudgeGuard.com. I hope this tip helps!
Samantha - November 11, 2007 11:23 PM
Frez - I think the reason you see a lot about photo retouching in your research is because I've found that a lot of people use graphics tablets for reasons I wouldn't normally think of. Some people use tablets because using a mouse hurts their wrist, arm, etc. Also, I have a feeling that a surprisingly large number of people only use tablets for photo editing - tables tend to aid greats when it come to freestyle selecting parts of an image and such.
I don't think there's any need to fear the Intuos3 6x11. That's the one I'm looking into buying. It seems that those of us interested in using tablets for illustration are not as large a percentage of the tablet users and I would have thought.
My best friend's younger sister [Emily] recently bought an Intuos (I believe it's a 6x8). She's a drawer and she does a lot of sketching on it. I got to test it out and it was quite amazing. The sensitivity feature was phenomenal but a little touchy. Although I must admit, I only got to play with it for about half an hour and Emily was MUCH better than I. They take a little practice.
Overall I have been very impressed with the product and seeing as I'll be majoring in Communication Design when i go off to college next fall, I'm interesting in getting a head start on one of these to further enhance my illustration skills. It's a competitive business so keep up with the latest tools!
Koni - January 23, 2008 6:30 PM
Hi Stephen,
I am a dinosaur who is so desppperate to be resurrected and re-invented! I used to do a lot of storyboards and illustrations way back in my days working in advertising. I had to say goodbye to my career to follow my husband's. That was more than a decade ago. Now, we're settled and I'm exploring the possibilities of making a comeback.
I've always been a "traditional" artist, meaning I've used actual paints and brushes that make your hands dirty, so can you just imagine how deeply stuck I am in the dark ages. Your reviews have been very helpful to help me understand all these new technologies.
My intention is to offer to do storyboards and illustrations working from my home. Are markers, pencils on papers really things of the past?. Should I go digital all the way? I'm no expert at all but from what I can gather it seems like Intuos3 is the best option for me, mainly because of the ink pen. Would 9 x 12 be the ideal size for what I want to do or the 6 x 8 will do just as good? It will be quite pricey and I have a very limited budget to re-tool my drawing board, so I have to think hard. Is included software bundle enough or I still have to get more? Is Intuos 3 Special Edition a better buy? What are your thoughts on buying used tablets? I read somewhere it can be risky. I would greatly appreciate if you can offer me some advice.
Many, many thanks,
Koni
Stephen DesRoches - January 23, 2008 8:57 PM
Koni. Those are some interesting questions and I'm a bit hesitant to recommend a tablet for what you need based on your experience.
The tablet is primarily just a replacement for a mouse that gives more control. You still need to know the software (either it be Photoshop, Painter or something else) very well to get the most out of a tablet.
The Intuos3 has it's advantages but I think the cheaper ones are just as good. I started out with the $100 graphire tablet. (now called the Bamboo)
The size of the tablet will be based on how big your screen is. They should be directly related. If your monitor is bigger then 19", then the smaller tablets are probably too small and you should think about getting a 6x8. Personally (and others will disagree with me) I think 9x12 is too big for almost anyone unless your looking for extremely fine detailed control on a giant monitor resolution.
I would not say that traditional art with pencils/pens are out. It's a difference of what you are more comfortable with and how you can produce the necessary results the quickest.
The Intuos3 Special Edition has a premium price for the name. Same thing but costs more.
Software bundle includes Photoshop Elements and Painter Elements. I'm not sure if those will do what you want but if you have never used them before, that will be a far bigger learning curve then using the tablet.
Overall. The tablet is just a much better option then using a mouse. If you can't do what you need with a mouse, the pen will not magically change that.
Hope that helps
mark - May 2, 2008 1:09 AM
Hi, thanks for the review. I have a question that is not quite related to this review. Could you please answer it? It would save me alot of research time. I want to learn digital art and want to buy a tablet pc and a professional level painting/drawing tablet program. I am very particular (I use a .005 size ink pen to sometimes).
I am assuming it is better for control to use a tablet pc than it is to use a digitizer tablet? Also, do you have suggestions on software I should check out?
Thank you so much!
James Gilbert - June 9, 2008 4:14 PM
I found these reviews while searching for an Intuos 2 or 3. As many others here, I was having a hard time making up my mind on the size of table. Very helpful review. I have Photoshop CS, and since I need to learn how to use it, stumbled upon a cool site called lynda.com. The videos on that site, for learning Photoshop CS, are authored by a gal named Tanya...and she uses a Intuos 2 tablet for some of the lessons. She showed comparisons between trying to draw something with her mouse, and then her tablet. What a difference! This has made me want (or think I need) a tablet. After reading all the reviews, and questions and comments, I just had to mention Lynda.com because I've been so pleased with their approach to teaching. FYI...
Hope that helps someone who wants to learn Photoshop, or Illustrator, etc.
ali - July 2, 2008 4:54 PM
Hi everyone
I just cant make up my mind, I am a mural artisit and want a tablet to help with sketching. I will be using my laptop so need something portable. so which do i choose price is not the problem I just want something that does what i need.
The more i read the more confused i get. help
ali - July 2, 2008 5:44 PM
Hi everyone
I just cant make up my mind, I am a mural artisit and want a tablet to help with sketching. I will be using my laptop so need something portable. so which do i choose price is not the problem I just want something that does what i need.
The more i read the more confused i get. help
Utah - October 20, 2008 4:05 PM
loser
Craig - October 21, 2008 6:32 PM
Here's another perspective from someone who owns both Intuos 3 (6x11) and Graphire (6x8 Bluetooth) tablets.
There are a couple of myths that need to be dispelled. The first one is that everyone can tell the difference between 512 and 1024 pressure levels. I seriously doubt that. If you are controlling transparency for example in CS4, your screen only has 256 levels of gray to begin with and even with 512 levels you have 2 pressure levels for each available gray level. I've been using Wacom's for over a decade and I can't tell any difference.
The next myth is you need a big tablet if you have a big screen. For using the mouse I typically redefine the area used to a small maybe 2x3" area on the tablet and find that is more than enough for my 1920 x 1200 laptop. Same at home with a 2560 x 1600 NEC monitor. Related is the myth that you need a wide aspect ratio tablet to match your wide aspect ratio monitor. I bought into that one but that too proved wrong, you move the pen/mouse and watch the screen - the relative aspect ratios don't make any difference.
If you're an artist and tracing large artwork then maybe you need a bigger tablet but mostly anything bigger than 6x8 is complete overkill and a waste of desk space. Not to mention you'll be getting tired of waving your arm back and forth a foot at a time.
So what are the real differences you should be looking for? Here are the ones that I found significant.
1. The Intuos pen is bigger, has a rubber grip, and replaceable tips. I've never worn out a tip and prefer the narrower pen because it feels more like a normal pen.
2. The surface on the Intuos is a plastic sheet that isn't glued down and lifts up and lets dirt underneath which can be very hard to get out. The Graphire is clear plastic and can have a photo or artwork placed underneath, I find this approach far preferable.
3. The Graphire has a pen holder at the top of the tablet. I find this preferable to the separate holders provided with both tablets.
4. If you leave the mouse on the pad with the Graphire, your PC or laptop will still go into standby. If the Intuos mouse is in pen mode (the mode I use) it will prevent the screensaver from activating and the machine going into standby. Wacom know about this and claim they can't fix it (except they did with the Graphire Bluetooth).
5. The buttons on the side may be useful to some (I had difficulty finding a use for them given I have my other hand on the keyboard, and CS4 has plenty of context menus that can be activated with a click), but they add significantly to the size of the tablet. The 6x11 is (IMHO) a big ugly slab of gray whereas the Graphire Bluetooth is (again IMHO) nicely styled and complements the modern look of my XPS laptop and NEC 3090WQXi nicely.
6. The Bluetooth feature is nice and makes one less thing I need to connect/disconnect when I move my laptop. The battery seems to last forever between charges so most of the time it doesn't need to be connected to anything. Less clutter and a neater desk is a benefit for me.
7. Pen/Mouse feel on the tablet. The Graphire mouse seems to glide more freely on the pad. The pens feel about the same to me (both are slightly scratchy feeling but not that noticeable when you are working).
8. Cost. About the same, in fact the Graphire Bluetooth is a bit cheaper.
9. Build Quality. The Graphire wins there, especially if you're moving around. I wouldn't throw the Intuous in a laptop case without some other protection like I would the Graphire. No cords to tangle with either, since for event work in the field there's no reason to even bother with the charger, you're never going to need it.
Overall I'm much happier with the Graphire 6x8 than I was with the Intuos 3 to the point that I plan to sell the Intuos 3 and buy another Graphire for home use. Even better I'll probably make money in the transaction.
Stephen DesRoches - October 21, 2008 7:17 PM
Craig, interesting points but a few things:
I do think the tablet size should be in proportion to screen size. It would be difficult to use a 4x5 on a 30" screen.
#1. I replaced the rubber grip Intuos pen with a traditional Intuos pen. Its much more similar to the Graphire.
I have worn out tips(nibs) in the past. They do wear down.
#2. Never had this problem with the Intuos but I have with the Graphire2
#3. Couldn't you just place the holder at top center on the Intuos?
#4. Can't comment on this because my mouse is still in the box.
#5. Agreed. I would like an Intuos without the buttons to save space.
#6. I really hate batteries (as much as I do wires)
I realize my original review is becoming old and comparing them now, the 6x8 graphire wireless is a serious consideration against the Intuos line.
Craig - October 21, 2008 7:52 PM
Products do evolve (at least that's the hope) and I think the Graphire 6x8 Bluetooth is a much better product than the Graphire 3 I had in my last job, and the Graphire tablets have been steadily heading upmarket. The Bamboo series are the apparent replacement at the low end, but I have to admit I'd have trouble submitting a work expense for something that has 'fun' in the name :-)
As for the size argument, I still don't see it. Your hands and arms are a fixed size. If I was working on a 65" projection screen should I be using a 30"x20" Wacom tablet. It's more to do with the available resolution needing to match screen resolution.
As an example my 30" NEC is 2560 x 1600. The Intuos3 is rated at 5080 lpi. That means I only need 1/2" x 1/3" to cover every pixel on my screen. Using a 2" x 3" area I'm covering each pixel on the screen with 6 lines (i.e. a 6x6 grid) on the pad, more than enough resolution really and going larger is just adding more overkill (and that's using the NEC as the example, hardly your average display).
As for the holder, yes I could place it at the top but I like how it's out of the way pushed into the tablet and it's convenient for travelling. My Intuos3 pen is always getting knocked over (not to mention stolen by my toddlers who see it as a fun toy daddy plays with).
I'm not a big fan of batteries either but the Graphire's battery is pretty cool. It's a cell phone battery, very small and Li-Ion Polymer by the look of it. If you leave the tablet plugged in you never need to worry about it and when I do events (I'm a professional photographer) it's easy just to grab it and go knowing that I probably won't use 1% of the available battery life in a normal 5-6 hour event.
#2 is a big one for me because I prefer to use one pad for mouse/pen. Partly because it provides a nice mouse pad and mostly because I prefer using a mouse in pen mode (1:1 correlation between position of mouse and cursor). The number of times I've found my home computer sitting idle (and sucking 500W+ of power) all day because someone forgot to take the mouse off the pad ... I'll probably be able to pay for the Graphire in saved electricity costs alone!
Stephen DesRoches - October 21, 2008 8:22 PM
Craig: I guess but at it's simplest form, the smaller the tablet in relation to the screen resolution, the fast the cursor will move.
I have used the 4x5 on a 1400x1200 resolution and it was a little jittery, I think that was pushing it. My regular setup is currently the full 6x8 on a 1680 resolution which works fine.
I actually don't remember the last time I held a mouse for anything. I've even adapted the pen for even the few games I play on occasion.
I also tend to just lay the pen on the desk and never use the pen holder.
Gale Leitch - December 13, 2008 12:02 AM
Today I bought an Intuos3 4x6 for $179 (on sale) but, after reading all these messages I wonder if I should go for the 6x8 (NOT on sale).
My current computer is a 17-inch G5. I use a 1440 x 900 resolution monitor setting.
The reason I've wanted a tablet is:
1) better control drawing, selecting, in Photoshop especially (photo editing and touch-up) and Illustrator vector drawing;
2) recently I've been experiencing pain in my right arm from the shoulder down - probably from so much clicking. I may replace my mouse with this tablet and pen.
I've found Stephen's and Craig's comments most helpful.
Two questions not yet raised. On the 4x6, the keypad is on the left. Is that annoying for a righthanded person? And... is the height difference from the table surface, combined with the ledge of the tablet, uncomfortable on one's wrist (on the 4x6)?
So, do you think I'll be okay with the 4x6?
I am so confused. If I get the go-ahead with the 4x6, that's great!
Thank you SO much!
Nessa - January 2, 2009 12:30 AM
I am planning on buying the new intuous. but i am wondering whether i should buy it off amazon for like 280 dollars over from wacom. but does buying from wacom have any perks?
Tedd - January 5, 2009 12:01 AM
Hi,
I found
Wacom Intuos3 6x8 PTZ630 for $329.99 and
Wacom-Intuos3 6x8 PTZ630AC for $289.00
Does anybody know the difference between the two,
beside the price?
Thank you
Adrian - January 11, 2009 7:12 AM
Hiii, I've already read the review and the comments but I'm still undecided..
Must I update my grapphire 4 A5 for a Intuos with the same size? Is good enough the Intuos feeling and pressure to do this change?
Thank you very much !
Fedora - January 20, 2009 2:57 PM
Thank you for the review, it really helped me decide which tablet I like. I've still got a problem though; I don't know which size Intuos to get. My laptop has a 15.4" widescreen and the 4x6 is more in my price range, but I know virtually nothing about tablets and am wondering if the 6x8 would work better. Any advice?
Stephen DesRoches - January 20, 2009 3:45 PM
Fedora: My best guess is that you have a screen resolution somewhere in between the 4x6 and 6x8. The key here is that the resolution matters, not the size of the screen.
I have used a 4x6 just fine on a screen resolution of 1400x1050. I have also used my 6x8 on a screen resolution 1280x800 which I find the tablet being too big.
I really depends on personal preference. I prefer to move my arm less so I like to use my 6x8 on 1680x1050 and my 4x6 on 1280x800. Others could very well disagree with me.
Fedora - January 20, 2009 5:39 PM
Ahh, okay. Mine is 1280x800, so the 4x6 will be perfect. Thank you so much!
Tamara - February 4, 2009 6:15 PM
Anyone owe a pc tablet. HP has a nice one. The tablet is made by wacom. I was wondering if it would be better to get the pc tablet because I need a new laptop anyway. Does anyone think its better to have them combine or separate?
Thank you
Tamara
adamkecap - March 1, 2009 3:00 PM
wow wacom ilove it that things so powerfull to me:p
i've use a wacom graphire4 (A6) about 2 years ago n all my job was done clearly nice..hehe..if i compare with mose who i've used in 6 years ago..like i used to be edit in photoshop (hair selection) my mose spend more than 60 minute n my brand new wacom spend only 15 minute...so i decide to throw away my mouse hehhee...but i don't setisfied for my graphire cos of the small n not confertable size for me..hiks:(
than in 2008 i decided to buy a new wacom intuos 3 (A6)..who i get from my jobs as digital artist ffreelance:D..
i use that until know..n make me confertable n more of portfolio that i get it's so clean, tidy n details..ehehhee..:)
but for mobile works i'll have a wacom graphire 4 (A5) cos i now that's so simple, strong n more practice than intuos that i use for my office works..
thanks
adamkecap
adamkecap - March 1, 2009 3:13 PM
ups sori i miss info ehhee..
than in 2008 i decided to buy a new wacom intuos 3 (A5)..for sure hehhe..
thx before:D